C Corp vs. S Corp vs. Partnership vs. LLC: Tax Impact & Liability

13.1 C Corp vs. S Corp vs. Partnership vs. LLC: Tax Impact & Liability

Choosing the right legal entity is one of the most critical decisions when establishing or restructuring a business. Each structure—C Corporation (C Corp), S Corporation (S Corp), Partnership, or Limited Liability Company (LLC)—carries distinct implications for taxes, liability, and ownership flexibility. These differences can significantly affect cash flow, distribution strategies, self-employment tax exposures, capital-raising options, and more.

In this section, we explore how double taxation compares to pass-through taxation, examine potential liability protections, highlight ownership constraints, and assess self-employment tax treatment. We also include practical examples, diagrams, tables, and best practices to help you make more informed choices. This content aligns with the Uniform CPA Examination Blueprints (Effective date: January 2025) for Tax Compliance and Planning (TCP), especially within the context of entity tax planning and formation strategies.

The Big Picture: Formation & Tax Regime

Understanding the distinctions among C Corps, S Corps, Partnerships, and LLCs begins with how each entity is formed and taxed.

• C Corp: Formed under state law, recognized as a separate taxpaying entity. Subject to corporate income tax, with shareholders taxed again when dividends are distributed.
• S Corp: Formed similarly to a C Corp but elects S status for pass-through taxation (part of Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code). Typically does not pay federal corporate tax; profits flow to shareholders’ individual returns.
• Partnership: Formed with two or more owners who agree to operate a business. Profits “pass through” to partners’ personal returns. Partnerships file an information return (Form 1065).
• LLC: An entity authorized under state law. By default, a multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership; a single-member LLC is disregarded for tax (treated as a sole proprietorship if owned by an individual). However, an LLC can elect to be taxed as a C Corp or S Corp.

Each classification has unique tax ramifications and liability protections. Let’s start with one of the most defining features: double taxation versus pass-through mechanics.

Double Taxation vs. Pass-Through Mechanics

Arguably the most significant distinction among these entity types lies in whether an entity is subject to corporate-level income tax.

C Corporation: Double Taxation

A C Corp is separate from its owners for tax purposes. It files Form 1120 and pays taxes on its taxable income at the corporate level. When the C Corp distributes earnings to its shareholders as dividends, shareholders are taxed again (on their individual returns). This results in the “double tax” phenomenon:

1. Corporate income is taxed once at the corporate level.
2. Dividends are taxed again at the shareholder level.

Qualified dividends for individual shareholders may benefit from a preferred rate (often up to 20% depending on the taxpayer’s marginal bracket), but the fundamental idea is two layers of taxation.

S Corporation: Pass-Through Treatment

An S Corp generally does not pay federal income tax at the corporate level (some states vary). Instead, the S Corp files an informational return (Form 1120-S) and passes income, losses, deductions, and credits to individual shareholders proportionally. Shareholders then report these amounts on their personal returns (Form 1040). While S Corps avoid double taxation at the federal level, there may be exceptions such as built-in gains taxes or excess passive income tax if the S Corp has certain leftover C Corp attributes.

Partnerships: Pass-Through Treatment

Partnerships themselves do not pay federal income tax. They file an information return (Form 1065) that allocates the partnership’s income, deductions, and credits to each partner via a Schedule K-1. Each partner reports their share on their personal tax return (e.g., Form 1040). The partnership model is highly flexible in allocating income, losses, and distributions, subject to the substantial economic effect rules under §704(b) and potential limitations.

LLCs: Flexible Classification

An LLC’s tax treatment is generally as a pass-through entity (a partnership for multi-member LLCs; a disregarded entity for single-member LLCs). However, LLCs can elect corporate treatment via Form 8832 (Entity Classification Election) and can further elect subchapter S if they meet S Corp requirements. In practice, many LLC owners favor pass-through tax treatment, but certain strategic scenarios might favor a C Corp election (e.g., for QBI planning, raising capital, or certain corporate-level benefits).

Ownership & Formation Constraints

Ownership constraints can be crucial in deciding which entity structure is feasible or optimal.

Below is a table comparing ownership constraints across these four entities:

Why Ownership Constraints Matter

• International Investors: If a business expects or desires foreign investment, a C Corp or an LLC (with C Corp election) might be more suitable, since S Corps prohibit foreign owners.
• Growth Trajectory: If raising capital from venture capitalists or private equity is a future goal, C Corps are often favored due to familiarity and ease of issuing multiple classes of stock.
• Family Businesses: S Corps are often chosen for small, closely held, U.S.-only family businesses. Partnerships or LLCs can also be structured for multi-generation estate planning.

Liability Protections

From a legal standpoint, personal liability protection for business debts and obligations often drives entity choice.

• C Corp and S Corp: Both structures provide a liability shield for shareholders, preventing personal assets from being used to satisfy corporate liabilities (absent fraud or personal guarantees).
• Partnership: Traditional general partnerships do not protect partners from personal liability for business debts. However, Limited Partnerships (LPs) or Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs) can limit liability for some or all partners.
• LLC: Offers liability protection for its members similar to that of a corporation, without the requirement to follow as many corporate formalities. States vary on specific protections and legal precedents, but generally, an LLC is recognized as a separate legal entity capable of shielding personal assets.

Potential Self-Employment Taxes

Self-employment tax (SECA) affects how active owners of pass-through entities pay Social Security and Medicare taxes on their share of business earnings.

• C Corp: Shareholders are not typically subject to self-employment tax on corporate dividends, but they must pay employment taxes as employees on wages. Salaries or wages to owner-employees are subject to FICA (employer and employee side).
• S Corp: Shareholder-employees must receive a reasonable salary for services provided. The salary portion is subject to employment tax (FICA), while the remaining pass-through income distributions are generally not subject to self-employment taxes. The IRS closely scrutinizes S Corps that pay owner-employees a minimal salary to avoid payroll taxes.
• Partnership: General partners (and some LLC members taxed as partnerships) pay self-employment tax on their share of ordinary business income from the partnership. The total net income allocated is often subject to self-employment tax unless the partner is a limited partner under carefully structured arrangements.
• LLC: If taxed as a partnership, the self-employment rules mirror those of a partnership. If the LLC is taxed as an S Corp, the same “reasonable salary” principle applies.

Below is a simplified table comparing self-employment tax considerations:

Illustrating the Tax Flow (Mermaid Diagram)

The following Mermaid diagram summarizes the flow of corporate income and how it reaches the owners under each structure, emphasizing differences between double taxation and pass-through approaches.

    flowchart LR
	    A[Business Income] --> B{C Corp}
	    B -->|Corporate Level Tax| C[After-Tax Earnings]
	    C -->|Dividends| D[Shareholders Pay Tax on Dividends]
	
	    A --> E{S Corp}
	    E -->|No Corporate Tax (Generally)| F[Flow-Through Income]
	    F -->|Divided by Shareholder %| G[Shareholder's 1040]
	
	    A --> H{Partnership}
	    H -->|No Entity-Level Tax| I[Schedule K-1 Income]
	    I -->|Pass-Through| J[Partner's 1040 (SE Tax May Apply)]
	
	    A --> K{LLC}
	    K -->|Default as Partnership| L[Pass-Through or Disregarded]
	    K -->|Elect S or C Status| M[Adjust Tax Flow Based on Election]
	    L --> N[Member's 1040 (SE Tax if Partnership)]
	    M -->|If C Corp| O[Double Taxation]
	    M -->|If S Corp| P[Reasonable Salary + Distribution Flow-Through]

Explanation of diagram flow:
• For C Corps, income is taxed first at the corporate level (B) and then again at dividends distribution (D).
• S Corps, Partnerships, and LLCs that elect pass-through status are not subject to federal corporate income tax (with some exceptions) and instead pass income through to the owners’ personal returns (G, J, N).

Detailed Look at Each Entity Type

C Corporation

1. Taxation: Subject to a corporate tax rate under the IRC (often a flat rate, e.g., 21% as of this writing). Shareholders pay tax on dividends.
2. Advantages:
   • Potential for unlimited growth via multiple classes of stock
   • Attractive to institutional and foreign investors
   • Well-established legal precedent in all states
3. Disadvantages:
   • Double taxation can be costly
   • Inflexible corporate formalities (e.g., annual meetings, board minutes)
   • Mindful planning required to avoid trapped earnings

S Corporation

1. Taxation: Income, losses, deductions, and credits pass through to shareholders. Generally no corporate-level tax, but watch out for built-in gains tax if converting from C Corp to S Corp.
2. Advantages:
   • Avoid double taxation at the entity level
   • Ability to minimize self-employment tax on distributions (subject to “reasonable salary” rules)
   • Liability protection similar to C Corp
3. Disadvantages:
   • Strict eligibility: max 100 shareholders, no foreign or corporate owners (generally)
   • Only one class of stock (voting differences allowed, but no differing economic rights)
   • Increased scrutiny around shareholder salaries

Partnership

1. Taxation: Pass-through by default. Partnerships file Form 1065. Income is allocated on Schedule K-1 and taxed at the partner’s individual rate.
2. Advantages:
   • Flexible allocation of income, losses, and distributions (substantial economic effect rules apply)
   • Generally simpler in terms of corporate formalities
   • Multiple entity types can be partners
3. Disadvantages:
   • General partners subject to self-employment tax for their share
   • Liability can be unlimited for general partners unless structured as an LLP or LP
   • Complexity in recourse vs. nonrecourse debt allocation

Limited Liability Company (LLC)

1. Taxation: By default, single-member LLCs are disregarded entities, and multi-member LLCs are taxed as partnerships. However, an LLC can elect corporate or S Corp status.
2. Advantages:
   • Limited personal liability for members (similar to corporate shareholders)
   • Flexibility to choose taxation method (partnership, S Corp, or C Corp)
   • Fewer state-imposed corporate formalities
3. Disadvantages:
   • Varying state rules regarding tax treatment or additional fees (e.g., franchise taxes)
   • Some investors or lenders may prefer a C Corp structure for standardized transactions
   • Potential complexity if multiple members desire different tax treatments

Comparative Case Studies

Below are two simplified scenarios illustrating how entity choice can have real-world implications:

Case Study 1: Fast-Growing Tech Startup

• Founders plan to raise funds from angel investors and venture capital firms.
• International investors may also be interested.
• Founders want to retain earnings to reinvest in R&D rather than distributing dividends.

In this scenario, a C Corp is often the default because:
• It supports unlimited shareholders, including foreign investors.
• Venture capitalists prefer a C Corp structure for legal and administrative familiarity.
• Retained earnings remain with the corporation, and there is potential to leverage lower corporate rates.

While pass-through entities might avoid double taxation, they tend to be less flexible in meeting VC expectations. Additionally, many institutional investors have legal or policy restrictions against investing in pass-throughs, making C Corp status more suitable.

Case Study 2: Family-Operated Business with Active Owners

• A family of three siblings opens a consulting partnership.
• They want liability protection but also want business profits to flow through directly to them in a tax-efficient manner.

An LLC with pass-through taxation might be ideal here:
• Limited liability for each sibling.
• Simple pass-through taxation via Schedule K-1, with each sibling paying tax on their share of income.
• Flexibility in allocation of profits and losses under the operating agreement, subject to economic effect rules.

Alternatively, if they wanted to reduce self-employment tax, an S Corp election could help, but they would need to ensure that each sibling receives a reasonable salary for services. The administrative overhead is slightly higher than a pure partnership but can yield payroll tax savings.

Best Practices & Common Pitfalls

1. Review State Requirements: The tax benefits of an entity type can differ by state. For instance, some states impose franchise or margin taxes.
2. Maintain Corporate Formalities: Even LLCs and S Corps must keep clear records. Ignoring formalities can lead to piercing the corporate veil.
3. Assess Future Growth Needs: If you anticipate raising capital or selling to a strategic buyer, the corporate structure might yield better outcomes. If you want flexibility in the distribution of profits and losses, a partnership or LLC might fit better.
4. Reasonable Compensation: For S Corps, paying unreasonably low salaries to avoid FICA taxes is a common trigger for IRS audits.
5. Converting Entities: Conversions from one structure to another (e.g., C to S, LLC to S Corp) can trigger unexpected tax consequences, such as built-in gains. Proper planning and professional advice are critical.

Practical Tips for CPA Exam Preparation

• Know the Forms: Familiarize yourself with Forms 1120 (C Corp), 1120-S (S Corp), 1065 (Partnership), and 8832 (Entity Classification). The exam may test your understanding of filing requirements and deadlines.
• Understand the Flow of Income: Expect questions on how pass-through income is reported (Schedules K-1, 1120-S, 1065) and the difference between that and double taxation.
• Focus on Eligibility Rules: S Corp eligibility is a frequent area of testing, including knowledge of acceptable shareholders, timely elections, and the 100-shareholder limit.
• Stay Updated: Keep an eye on any legislative changes that may alter entity-level tax rates, self-employment tax rules, or pass-through deduction frameworks.

For more details on Corporate Income Computation and related corporate-level taxation, see Chapter 8. For deeper coverage of Partnerships and LLCs, consult Chapter 11. S Corp specifics are found in Chapter 10.

References & Further Reading

• IRS Publication 542, Corporations
• IRS Publication 3402, Taxation of Limited Liability Companies
• IRS Form 2553 Instructions (Electing S Corporation Status)
• Chapter 10 (S Corporations) and Chapter 11 (Partnerships & LLCs) of this book for deeper operational details
• Chapter 14 and 15 for ongoing planning and advanced S Corporation strategies

Quiz: Choosing Business Entities for Tax Efficiency

For Additional Practice and Deeper Preparation

TCP CPA Hardest Mock Exams: In-Depth & Clear Explanations

Tax Compliance & Planning (TCP) CPA Mocks: 6 Full (1,500 Qs), Harder Than Real! In-Depth & Clear. Crush With Confidence!

• Tackle full-length mock exams designed to mirror real TCP questions.
• Refine your exam-day strategies with detailed, step-by-step solutions for every scenario.
• Explore in-depth rationales that reinforce higher-level concepts, giving you an edge on test day.
• Boost confidence and minimize anxiety by mastering every corner of the TCP blueprint.
• Perfect for those seeking exceptionally hard mocks and real-world readiness.

Disclaimer: This course is not endorsed by or affiliated with the AICPA, NASBA, or any official CPA Examination authority. All content is for educational and preparatory purposes only.